The Gatekeeper

The man was old. His skin was lined and brown like tooled leather. His clothes were worn but well mended. They now fit him loosely and it wasn’t clear if they always had fitted him this way, Perhaps he wore loose robes to keep him cool in summer and warm when the biting wind blew down along the road from the mountains. Or had his body age-wizened leaving him with loose clothing.

With the sun he rose and after a small breakfast went to the gate of the walled city. The road that passed the gate was well-travelled, but not by many. There was another city a half-day walk in either direction down the dusty road. Most of the travelers walked; a few had loaded beasts or pulled loaded two-wheeled carts. There were no horses here.

The old man fitted himself into a niche by the gate and read. In late morning a young boy would come with his mother. They would bring cistern of water and offer it to travelers without charge. They sold small vegetable cakes for a copper each.

The city was the halfway point. Most drank, the water ate the cake, and walked on. The old man read what most assumed was scripture.

From the road, a man would call out “You there, Old man,” To these,  the woman and boy seemed invisible. The old man would raise his head and smile,. “How can I help you traveler?”

The man would complain about the heat or the cold and say he was thinking about an early end to the day..

“What kind of people live in this city?”

“Where are you coming from?” the old man would cheerfully inquire and the traveler would tell.. “Oh, what kind of people did you find there?”

The traveler would sneer, “They were venal and mean. They looked like they would beat me, Everyone tried to cheat me, but I was too smart for that. They served me garbage and day old food and thought that I would sleep on last month’s straw, telling me it was all they had.. It was awful!.”

“Alas, traveler. This city is filled with those people as well. It’s best to walk on down the road. Perhaps you’ll have better luck there.”

Some such travelers thanked the old man or threw a copper in the dirt at his feet. Most did not. The old man went back to reading.

On occasion a person would buy something from the boy and his mother, smile and converse with them.

Then this person would siddle over toward the gate and say, “Excuse me, Grandfather. I am sorry to disturb your study.”

The old man would look up and smile, “’Tis naught but some old poems. How can I help you traveler?”

The traveler would then ask about the poems or tell his own name and ask the old man’s. Eventually pleasantries would be dispensed with and the conversation would proceed as before.

“What kind of people live in this city?”

“Where are you coming from?” the old man would cheerfully inquire and the traveler would tell. “Oh, what kind of people did you find there?”

“Oh ‘twas wonderful! Everywhere people offered to help me. Our dealings were always fair. They fed me well and I slept on the same straw they themselves used.”

“You will be most welcome here traveler for here you will find people of the same kind. Please come in..”

This story is old. I believe it is a story told by Sufis, the Islamic mystics who used stories to teach lessons of right living, but the story may be older than that.

I first heard it from a trainer in a management training program. The lessons he taught were that people often perform according to your expectations.

It is a story about life orientations. If you expect to find people “venal and mean” you will find plenty. If you expect that people will be helpful, giving and fair, you will find them so.

Of course, the old man, the gate keeper, has a different perspective. It is his job to sort those who join his community. If people find others venal and mean then they are likely so themselves and he sends them elsewhere.

If they find others helpful, giving and fair he warmly welcomes them.

The gatekeeper was the keeper of the culture; he conducted screening interviews.

I worked at a small consulting firm that conducted many selection interviews. To many applicants it seemed like they “interviewed with everyone at the company.” In the beginning that might have literally true, but even as we grew it wasn’t unusual to have more than ten interviews.

I remember one candidate. This person had been a partner in a large firm and was put-out to be “interviewing with kids.” A former partner with a track record as a “rainmaker,” was something the firm needed.

The junior associates universally said “No.” They found this person “arrogant, demeaning, and not respectful to them and to clients talked about during the interview.”

The partner who brought in the applicant was angry, sputtering “Perhaps junior associates can bring in million dollar projects?!” In the end, the firm made no offer to the rainmaker. Protecting the culture was more important.

This was around the time that Robert Sutton published The No Ass-hole Rule: Building a Civilized Workplace and Surviving One That Isn’t. Several people at the firm used the book’s title as a way of justifying culture building and culture protection.

These days there is quite a lot of discussion and lamentation about working for bullies, narcissists, sociopaths, psychopaths and other generally unpleasant people.

I recently responded to one social media post:

First, Don’t be that guy.

If you find out you are that guy, get help. Change or stay home.

If you work for that guy and you are close -tell him -ever-so-gently- “Hey, you know- you might be that guy.” It might be a good idea to get help from colleagues before you do this because jerks can be vindictive. (In any case, don’t expect to be thanked.)

It is better if you can keep jerks outside the gates to begin with.

“What kind of people were at the last place you worked?”

Please scroll down to comment.

If you like what you’ve read, please subscribe. Click on the button below you to receive 1-2 new posts per week. No ads, no affiliate links. I will never sell, trade, or otherwise distribute your information. You can unsubscribe any time. Just click the unsubscribe button on the email.

Please join the conversation by scrolling down and leaving a comment

        To subscribe and receive 1-2 posts per week please click the button below   No ads, no affiliate links and I will not sell trade or otherwise distribute your information.

You may also like. . .

 Please contribute your thoughts in a comment. The author will be notified, but may not respond to every comment. The site reserves the right to delete comments it deems off topic, offensive, or spam.

4 Comments

  1. David Ford

    Having a gatekeeper of the culture is a good idea. Culture is everything as Peter Drucker said “Culture eats strategy for breakfast.” In a previous life, two companies removed, the culture was awful and very destructive.

    Reply
    • Alan Culler

      Absolutely, David! Shared Beliefs, Values, Behavioral Norms -the long shadow of the founders.

      Reply
  2. Roger Kellett

    Alan,
    I wholeheartedly agree w/ David Ford’s comment, however my impression was somewhat different… What went through my mind was that people see the same things everywhere, but their interpretation / processing of what they see can honestly be very different.

    I want to say the second man was different on the “inside”. Even though he saw all the same things as the very rational first man, his mindset was to be cheerful with the man at the gate. The second man was not ignorant or stupid, he displayed people skills and sensitivity.

    No one really knows what is around the next corner: could be wonderful or could be awful. Regardless of one’s situation, people can honestly see the world and people as decrepit or beautiful. In black and white terms, the world is both at once.

    My experience both professional and personal is that some folks (usually very honest, intelligent, and pragmatic) see the world as it is: full of shysters, war mongers, murderers, etc. Their views are based on facts. I was one of these rational people for most of my life.

    On the flip side, a counter view (one that has risen up in me as I drift into very old man status)… It’s that the world is what it is, get over it. Adopt an intellectual and spiritual stance to make sure that you do your damndest every day to spread joy at work, home, worship, and with strangers. Also, quit lamenting that the world and people therein all all sick, perverted, criminally insane, and mean shysters.

    Somebody somewhere called this approach to life as having the “joy of joy”. Professional experience and working with homeless people has taught me that a positive outlook can mean just about everything, especially for the down and out. I’m make no claims of my own perfection, but I’ve chosen “joy” as a lifestyle.

    Reply
    • Alan Culler

      Wow, Roger!
      “people can honestly see the world and people as decrepit or beautiful. In black and white terms, the world is both at once.”
      Very true.
      To me the gatekeeper’s job is to weed out those people who see the world in solely negative terms because however rational these people might be they are a vexations to the spirit to be around.
      Wouldn’t you rather hang out with someone who says “I’ve chosen “joy” as a lifestyle.”
      The follow up story about Katzenbach was about gatekeepers and protectors of the culture. Ultimately during the 2007 meltdown they failed to grow and were acquired. I’m sure there were some who looked back at turning down the “rainmaker” and regretted that decision. I think it was the right one.

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *